| Platinum | Toppers Pizza |
| Gold | Chi Chi's Pizza |
| Silver | Piccola Trattoria |
| Bronze | Vincenzo's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ameci Pizza Kitchen |
| Top Pick | BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse |
| Top Pick | Mod Pizza |
| Top Pick | Slice House |
| Top Pick | Tomato Joe's Pizza |
| Italia Panetteria & Deli |